These miscellaneous examples of SHM go beyond springs and
pendulums. Two SHMs of the same frequency along one line add like vectors into another SHM,
A2=A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ; at right angles they trace straight lines, ellipses, circles and
Lissajous figures. The same "restoring force =−kx" test also gives the periods of a liquid in a U-tube, a floating
body, a tunnel through the Earth, a ball in a bowl and a gas-cushioned piston. Miscellaneous SHM examples are a
favourite source of JEE Advanced and JEE Main questions.
On this page1Same-line superposition2Is it SHM?3Perpendicular SHMs4U-tube5Floating body6Earth tunnel7Bowl8Gas piston9Mind map
Key Formulas - Quick Reference
★ Must learnSame line, same ω: x=Asin(ωt+ε) with A=A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ
tanε=A1+A2cosδA2sinδ (measured from the phase of A1)
Different frequencies: periodic (if ω1/ω2 is rational) but not SHM
★ Must learnPerpendicular, same ω: A12x2+A22y2−A1A22xycosδ=sin2δ
★ Must learnU-tube: T=2π2gL (L = total length of the liquid column)
Floating body: T=2πgd (d = depth immersed at rest)
★ Must learnTunnel through a uniform Earth (any chord): T=2πR/g≈84.6min
Ball in a bowl: T=2πgR−r (sliding), 2π5g7(R−r) (rolling solid sphere)
Gas piston: T=2πP0AmL (isothermal); replace P0 by γP0 if adiabatic
1. Combining Two SHMs Along the Same Line
If two restoring forces, each proportional to displacement, act on a particle, the resulting motion is the
combination (superposition) of two simple harmonic motions: the displacements simply add.
1.1 Same frequency: the vector (phasor) method
Let x1=A1sinωt and x2=A2sin(ωt+δ). Expanding and collecting the sinωt and
cosωt terms:
x=(A1+A2cosδ)sinωt+(A2sinδ)cosωt=Asin(ωt+ε)
A=A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ,tanε=A1+A2cosδA2sinδ
The result is again SHM with the same frequency. The formulas are exactly those of vector addition: draw each
amplitude as a vector at its phase angle and add head to tail. The method extends to three or more SHMs.
Figure 1: Treat each amplitude as a vector at its phase angle. For A1=3, A2=4, δ=90∘: resultant A=5 at ε=53∘.Figure 2: x1=3sinωt (grey), x2=4cosωt (amber) and x=x1+x2 (orange). The sum is again a sine curve with the same period, amplitude 5: still SHM.
1.2 Rules before you add
Convert every term into the sine form, with ωt carrying a positive sign (cosωt=sin(ωt+π/2),
−sinωt=sin(ωt+π)).
Make every amplitude positive (absorb a minus sign as +π in the phase).
Take A1 as the amplitude of the SHM with the smaller phase; δ is the phase difference.
Write the result as x=Anetsin(phase of A1+ε).
Phase difference δ
Resultant amplitude
Remark
0 (in phase)
A1+A2
maximum
π/2
A12+A22
vectors at right angles
2π/3 with A1=A2=a
a
equal SHMs 120∘ apart
π (opposite)
∣A1−A2∣
minimum; zero if equal
1.3 Different frequencies
If x=A1sinω1t+A2sinω2t with ω1=ω2, the sum is not SHM: its
acceleration is not proportional to −x. It is periodic when ω1/ω2 is a ratio of whole numbers, with a
period equal to the least common multiple of the two periods. (Close frequencies give beats, studied with
waves.)
Figure 3: x=sinωt+sin2ωt repeats every T=2π/ω, but the shape is not a sine curve: periodic, not SHM.
Exam Trick
"Is it SHM?" in ten seconds. Reduce the
expression to a sum of sines and cosines. One frequency only (plus possibly a constant) means SHM; a constant
only shifts the mean position.
Expression
Rewritten
SHM?
sinωt+cosωt
2sin(ωt+π/4)
yes, amplitude 2
sin2ωt
21−21cos2ωt
yes, about x=21, frequency 2ω
sinωtcosωt
21sin2ωt
yes, frequency 2ω
sin3ωt
43sinωt−41sin3ωt
no (two frequencies), periodic
sinωt+sin2ωt
two frequencies
no, periodic
e−ωtsinωt
decaying
no, not periodic (damped)
Figure 4: x=Asin2ωt=2A−2Acos2ωt: SHM about x=A/2 with amplitude A/2, angular frequency 2ω and period π/ω (Solved Example 6). Squaring halved the period.
Key idea
Same line and same frequency: the sum is always SHM of that frequency. Any second frequency spoils it.
2. Two SHMs at Right Angles
Let x=A1sinωt and y=A2sin(ωt+δ), same frequency, perpendicular directions. Eliminate t:
sinωt=x/A1 and cosωt=1−x2/A12. Substituting in y/A2=sinωtcosδ+cosωtsinδ
and squaring gives the path
A12x2+A22y2−A1A22xycosδ=sin2δ
which is, in general, an ellipse.
Same line
Displacements add as numbers: x=x1+x2. Same ω gives SHM with A=A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ.
At right angles
Displacements add as vectors: the particle moves in a plane. Same ω gives a line, an ellipse or a circle, not a 1-D SHM.
δ
Path
Equation
0
straight line through the origin, positive slope
y=A1A2x
π
straight line, negative slope
y=−A1A2x
π/2
ellipse along the axes
A12x2+A22y2=1
π/2 and A1=A2=A
circle (uniform circular motion)
x2+y2=A2
any other value
tilted ellipse
general equation above
Figure 5: x=A1sinωt, y=A2sin(ωt+δ). Lines at δ=0,π; ellipses in between; arrows show the (clockwise) sense for 0<δ<π. With A1=A2 and δ=90∘ the ellipse is a circle.
Exam Trick
Sense of
rotation. For x=A1sinωt, y=A2sin(ωt+δ): if 0<δ<π the point moves
clockwise; if π<δ<2π, anticlockwise. Check quickly by finding the direction of motion at
t=0.
These paths are called Lissajous figures. With unequal frequencies the figures become more intricate:
Figure 6: Lissajous figures for unequal frequencies ωx:ωy. The path closes only when the ratio is a ratio of whole numbers; the motion is periodic but the path is not an ellipse.
Quick Recall: tap to checkTwo perpendicular SHMs of equal amplitude and frequency differ in phase by π/2. What is the path?
A circle.
What is the path for δ=0?
A straight line y=(A2/A1)x.
Is x=sin2ωt SHM?
Yes: x=21−21cos2ωt, SHM about x=21 with angular frequency 2ω.
Figure 7: Two questions sort every combination. Only same frequency + same line gives SHM again, with A=A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ.
3. SHM in Other Systems
Every system below is solved with the same test: displace by a small x, find the restoring force, write it as
F=−keffx, identify the moving mass meff, then T=2πmeff/keff.
3.1 Liquid in a U-tube
Liquid of density ρ fills a length L of a U-tube of cross-section A. Mass =LAρ.
Let the level rise by y on one side and fall by y on the other. The unbalanced column of height 2y weighs
2yAρg and acts to restore the levels: F=−(2Aρg)y.
ω2=LAρ2Aρg=L2g, so
T=2π2gL
It does not depend on the density
or the cross-section.
Figure 8: The extra column of height 2y weighs 2yAρg and pushes the whole liquid (mass LAρ) back: ω2=2g/L, T=2πL/2g.
3.2 Floating body
A body of mass m and uniform cross-section A floats upright in a liquid of density σ with depth d
immersed: mg=Adσg.
Pushed down by a further x, extra buoyancy Axσg acts upwards: F=−(Aσg)x.
ω2=mAσg=dg, so
T=2πgd
For a cylinder of height h and
density ρ, d=hρ/σ. (Viscous drag and the moving liquid are ignored.)
Figure 9: Pushing the cylinder down by x adds buoyancy Axσg (restoring). With d the depth at rest, T=2πd/g=2πhρ/σg.
3.3 Tunnel through the Earth
Inside a uniform Earth, only the mass within radius r attracts: g(r)=gRr.
In a smooth tunnel along a diameter, at distance x from the centre F=−Rmgx: SHM with ω=g/R.
Along a chord, the gravity Rmgr has a component Rmgx along the chord, x measured from its middle: the
same ω.
T=2πgR≈84.6min
A body dropped in takes T/2≈42min to reach the other end,
passing the centre at vmax=gR≈7.9km s−1.
Figure 10: Inside a uniform Earth, gravity grows linearly with distance from the centre, so along any straight smooth tunnel F=−Rmgx and T=2πR/g≈84.6 min.
Same number, three places.2πR/g≈84.6 min is also the period
of a satellite skimming the Earth's surface and of an infinitely long pendulum. All three are governed by g and R
alone.
3.4 Ball in a bowl
A small ball of radius r at the bottom of a smooth spherical bowl of radius R moves on a circle of radius R−r
about the bowl's centre: it is a pendulum of length R−r, so T=2π(R−r)/g. If the ball rolls without
slipping, its rotational energy adds to the inertia.
Figure 11: A ball in a bowl swings like a pendulum of length R−r about the bowl's centre O. Sliding (smooth bowl): T=2π(R−r)/g; rolling solid sphere: T=2π7(R−r)/5g.
JEE Advanced
Rolling ball.
Kinetic energy =21mv2+21⋅52mr2(rv)2=21⋅57mv2,
so meff=57m while the restoring force stays −R−rmgs. Hence
T=2π5g7(R−r). For a ring or hollow cylinder replace 57 by 1+K2/r2.
3.5 Piston on a gas column
A piston of mass m and area A traps a gas column of length L at equilibrium pressure P0 (which already
balances the atmosphere and the piston's weight).
Push the piston in by x. Isothermally, P0AL=P(L−x)A, so the pressure rises by ΔP≈P0Lx.
Restoring force F=−LP0Ax, so
T=2πP0AmL
For rapid (adiabatic) compression
ΔP=γP0x/L and P0→γP0.
Figure 12: Pushing the piston down by x raises the gas pressure by P0x/L (isothermal), a restoring force P0Ax/L: T=2πmL/P0A. For a quick (adiabatic) squeeze use γP0.
System
keff
meff
Period
U-tube
2Aρg
LAρ
2πL/2g
Floating body
Aσg
m=Adσ
2πd/g
Earth tunnel
mg/R
m
2πR/g
Ball in bowl (sliding)
mg/(R−r)
m
2π(R−r)/g
Gas piston (isothermal)
P0A/L
m
2πmL/P0A
Key idea
Density, cross-section and mass often cancel: U-tube 2πL/2g, floating body 2πd/g, Earth tunnel 2πR/g.
Quick Recall: tap to checkDoes the period of liquid in a U-tube depend on the liquid's density?
No: T=2πL/2g depends only on the column length.
How long does a ball take to fall through a tunnel along any chord of the Earth?
Half a period, about 42min, whatever the chord.
A piston is pushed in quickly (adiabatic). What replaces P0 in T?
γP0, so the period becomes shorter.
4. The Whole Chapter on One Page
Figure 13: The whole chapter on one screen. Every branch uses the same idea: find the restoring force or torque, write it as −kx or −kθ, and read off ω.
Key idea
One test solves every SHM problem: displace slightly, find the restoring force or torque, write it as −kx or −kθ, and ω=k/m or k/I.
5. Solved Examples
Solved Example 1
x1=3sinωt and x2=4cosωt. Find (i) the amplitude of the resultant SHM, (ii) the equation of the resultant SHM.
Solution:
Write both in sine form: x1=3sinωt, x2=4sin(ωt+π/2), so δ=π/2.
A=32+42+2(3)(4)cos90∘=25=5. tanε=3+4cos90∘4sin90∘=34,
so ε≈53∘.
Answer: A=5; x=5sin(ωt+53∘) (Figures 1 and 2).
Solved Example 2
x1=5sin(ωt+30∘) and x2=10cosωt. Find the amplitude of the resultant SHM.
Solution:
x2=10sin(ωt+90∘), so the phase difference is 90∘−30∘=60∘.
A=52+102+2(5)(10)cos60∘=25+100+50=175.
Answer: A=57≈13.2.
Solved Example 3
A particle is subjected to two SHMs x1=A1sinωt and x2=A2sin(ωt+π/3). Find (a) the displacement at t=0, (b) the maximum speed, (c) the maximum acceleration.
Solution:
(a) At t=0: x1=0, x2=A2sin3π=23A2. So x=23A2.
The resultant is SHM of the same ω with A=A12+A22+2A1A2cos(π/3)=A12+A22+A1A2.
Three SHMs of equal amplitude a and equal frequency act along the same line with phases 0, 2π/3 and 4π/3. The resultant amplitude is (A) 3a (B) a3 (C) a (D) 0
Solution:
The three amplitude vectors are 120∘ apart and equal: head to tail they form a closed equilateral triangle.
Answer: (D). The particle stays at rest.
Solved Example 5
A particle moves so that x=3sinωt and y=4cosωt. Find the path and the sense of motion.
Solution:
3x=sinωt, 4y=cosωt, so 9x2+16y2=1: an ellipse with semi-axes 3 and 4.
At t=0 the particle is at (0,4) and x is increasing, so it moves right from the top: clockwise.
(Here δ=π/2, inside 0 to π.)
Solved Example 6
Show that x=Asin2ωt is SHM and find its mean position, amplitude and period.
Solution:
x=2A−2Acos2ωt. So x−2A=−2Acos2ωt and
dt2d2x=−(2ω)2(x−2A).
Answer: SHM about x=A/2, amplitude A/2, angular frequency 2ω, period ωπ.
Solved Example 7
A U-tube contains a liquid column of total length 40cm. The liquid is disturbed. Find the period of oscillation (g=10m s−2).
Solution:
T=2π2gL=2π200.40=2π(0.141).
Answer: T≈0.89s.
Solved Example 8
A wooden cylinder of density 600kg m−3 and height 20cm floats upright in water. It is pushed down slightly and released. Find the period (g=9.8m s−2).
Solution:
Depth immersed d=hσρ=20×1000600=12cm.
T=2πgd=2π9.80.12. Answer: T≈0.70s.
Solved Example 9
A straight smooth tunnel is dug along a diameter of the Earth (radius 6.4×106m, g=9.8m s−2). A ball is dropped into it. Find (a) the time to reach the other end, (b) the speed at the centre.
Solution:
ω=g/R; T=2π9.86.4×106≈5.08×103s≈84.6min.
(a) From one end to the other is half a period: about 42min.
(b)vmax=Aω=Rg/R=gR≈7.9km s−1.
Solved Example 10
A piston of mass 1kg and area 10cm2 traps a gas column 50cm long at equilibrium pressure 1.0×105Pa in a smooth cylinder. Find the period of small oscillations, assuming isothermal changes.
Solution:
keff=LP0A=0.50(1.0×105)(1.0×10−3)=200N m−1.
T=2πkeffm=2π2001. Answer: T≈0.44s.
Solved Example 11
A solid ball of radius 0.10m rolls without slipping inside a spherical bowl of radius 0.80m. Find the period of small oscillations (g=9.8m s−2).
Solution:
T=2π5g7(R−r)=2π5(9.8)7(0.70)=2π0.10.
Answer: T≈1.99s.
Solved Example 12
Liquid in a U-tube oscillates with period T. It is replaced by a liquid of half the density, keeping the same total length of the liquid column. The new period is (A) T/2 (B) T (C) 2T (D) 2T
Solution:
Restoring force =2Aρgy and moving mass =LAρ: the density cancels, T=2π2gL.
Same L means the same period.
Answer: (B). Halving the density halves both the restoring force and the mass.
Practice Questions
Find the amplitude of x=6sinωt+8sin(ωt+π).Answer: ∣6−8∣=2.
Find the amplitude and phase of x=sinωt+3cosωt.Answer: 2; x=2sin(ωt+π/3).
Is x=sinωtcos2ωt SHM?Answer: No: 21(sin3ωt−sinωt) has two frequencies.
x=2sinωt, y=2sin(ωt+π). Describe the path.Answer: The straight line y=−x between (−2,2) and (2,−2).
A U-tube has mercury of total length L. If the mercury is replaced by water of the same column length, how does the period change?Answer: It stays the same: T=2πL/2g does not depend on density.
A cube floats with 4cm immersed. Find its period of vertical oscillation (g=π2m s−2).Answer: 2π0.04/π2=0.4s.
On a planet of half the Earth's radius and the same density, how does the tunnel period compare?Answer: The same: R/g is unchanged because g∝ρR.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Watch out
Adding amplitudes directly. Amplitudes add like vectors: A1+A2 only when δ=0.
Using δ without converting cos terms to sin first. cosωt=sin(ωt+π/2).
Ignoring a minus sign: −sinωt is sin(ωt+π), which changes δ by π.
Calling the sum of two different frequencies SHM. It is periodic at best, never simple harmonic.
Taking the U-tube column length as one arm. L is the total length of liquid.
Using the whole height of a floating body in T=2πd/g. Use the immersed depth d.
Forgetting rotational kinetic energy for a ball rolling in a bowl (the factor 7/5).
Measuring x from the Earth's centre in a chord tunnel. Along the chord, x is measured from the chord's midpoint.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you add two simple harmonic motions of the same frequency?
Treat each amplitude as a vector at its phase angle and add them head to tail. The result is SHM of the same frequency with amplitude A12+A22+2A1A2cosδ, where δ is the phase difference. First convert both motions to the sine form.
Is the sum of two SHMs always SHM?
Only if both have the same frequency and act along the same line. With different frequencies the sum is periodic (if the ratio of frequencies is rational) but not simple harmonic, because acceleration is no longer proportional to displacement. At right angles the particle moves on a line, ellipse or circle.
What are Lissajous figures?
Lissajous figures are the paths traced when a particle performs two SHMs at right angles. For equal frequencies they are straight lines, ellipses or circles depending on the phase difference. For unequal frequencies in a whole-number ratio they form closed loops such as the figure of eight.
What is the time period of liquid oscillating in a U-tube?
For a liquid column of total length L in a uniform U-tube, T=2πL/2g. The extra column of height 2y supplies the restoring force. The period does not depend on the liquid's density or the tube's cross-section.
How long would it take to fall through a tunnel through the Earth?
Inside a uniform Earth gravity is proportional to distance from the centre, so a body in a smooth tunnel performs SHM with period two pi root R over g, about 84.6 minutes. It reaches the other end in half a period, about 42 minutes, whatever the chord.
Why does a floating body oscillate in SHM?
When pushed down by x, a floating body of cross-section A gains extra buoyancy Aσgx proportional to x and directed upwards. That is a restoring force of the SHM type, giving T=2πd/g with d the immersed depth at rest.
Which miscellaneous SHM questions come in JEE Advanced?
JEE Advanced likes combinations of SHMs with the phasor method, perpendicular SHMs and their paths, the Earth tunnel along a chord, rolling bodies in bowls, gas-cushioned pistons with adiabatic changes, and checking whether a given function represents SHM. The restoring-force test solves all of them.
Are these miscellaneous SHM topics in the NEET syllabus?
NEET mainly asks the resultant amplitude of two SHMs, whether an expression like sine squared is SHM, and simple systems such as the U-tube and floating body. Detailed Lissajous figures, rolling in bowls and gas pistons are more typical of JEE, but the formulas are quick to learn.
Previous year questions on Miscellaneous Examples of SHM
5 questions from past papers, each with a step-by-step solution.